News & Insights: Offer stage
Do you accept a counter offerDo you accept a counter offer
A counter offer is where you hand your notice to your current employer and they come back with their own offer, just to keep you even though this offer was not on the cards prior to you handing your notice in. What we do find is that the small number of people who do accept a counter offer are often times making a mistake, out of this small number around 75% are then looking for a new job again within 6-12 months, The reason being they have been let go. In some sectors this can be as high as 90%.
So what is the cause of this? Essentially your employer is trying to see if you can be bought out, as a test of your commitment. You’re not actually meant to accept a counter offer, it’s a test in determination and perseverance, your current employer will be happy to see your conviction as it shows how serious you are about the move.
key reasons you wanted to leave
Remind yourself of the key reasons you wanted to leave in the first place.
Whether that was money or travel, a lack of career progression, undesirable working hours or lacking work life balance. Remind yourself at that counter offer stage of the key reasons you wanted to leave.
Below we’ve listed the key reasons people have left their job in the past, and why they should be remembered in the face of a counter offer.
- Money
- Travel
- Careerprogression
- Undesirable location
- Lack of socials
You may even be promised these can be easily worked in if you stay, but remember they’re trying to convince you to stay, if these points were so easy to implement, they’d already be there, right?
When you’ve been given a counter offer, here are 3 subjects worth thinking about, we ask all candidates to do this at this stage:
Delayed recognition
If you’re worth your increased salary and responsibilities, why wasn’t this recognised before you handed in your notice? Part of your frustration from the outset may be that you’re undervalued, and if it takes your resignation for this to be noticed you may be better off with an organisation that is more proactive in helping you fulfil your career ambitions.
If it’s not about the money
A counter-offer may not just be about a pay rise, it could aim to address other key motivators like level of responsibly or work life balance. Unless salary was the sole purpose for looking at new opportunities, counter-offers are rarely the answer. In our experience, most people who accept them find themselves looking for a new job a few months later, when the situation that caused them to explore the market, remains unresolved.
Trust issues
Once your employer knows that you’ve been interviewing elsewhere, you demonstrate that you have the potential to be disloyal to the company. You may no longer be seen as a team player, and could potentially be first out the door if there is an internal reorganisation.
Please call your recruitment partner as they can help to discuss the options available to you if you’re starting to have doubts about your time with a business. It can sometimes feel like it’s the better option to stay put and tough it out, but in the long run it is often better to move on to something better.
HtE Recruitment News & Insights
This news and insights page has been written by Josh our Recruitment & Marketing Coordinator. HtE Recruitment take no responsibility for this post.

Other CV & Interview tips:
The steps you will have when job hunting – CV & Interview tips
Steps to take when thinking about a new job As we all know, looking for a new job can be a challenge, but with proper planning and preparation, you can be ahead of the curve and give yourself the right start to build your job searching on. When looking for a new job,...
Why do Recruitment Agencies call candidates – CV & Interview tips
Why do Recruitment Agencies call candidates To start, we need to explain there is two types of Recruitment firms. You have Recruitment Agencies and Employment Businesses. A Recruitment agency offers a finders service to clients to source candidates and a Employment...
The 7 reasons why it is time to move jobs – Interview & Career tips
The 7 reasons why it is time to move jobs Everyone from time to time has a bad day or week, while this should not be a reason for leaving a job if it becomes more consistent and starts to span months it may be a sign you should move. Although just having a week, being...
Researching is key when job hunting – Interview & Career tips
Researching is key when job hunting When you are job hunting, it is essential to research about the company you are looking to work at. This will help at the interview stage but more important, it will give you more clear ideas of if this actually is the right...
How to stand out in the Job market – News & Insights
Standing out in the job market Have you ever tried to find someone at the football match or on a London Underground train? Then you know how hard it is to find someone who is not standing out. This can be the same when job hunting, many fail to find a way to stand out...
Small talk at the start of a interview – Interview & Career tips
How to use small talk in an interview In an interview, it is really important to start the interview off in a positive way that shows your keen to be a part of the organisation. Although small talk may seem like a talent, it’s a practice that anyone can master. Having...
Phone answering tips for interviews and sales – News & Insights
Answering phone and sales calls in the workplace This is an area you don’t learn at school and with everything increasingly being on Whatsapp and over the phone, for first timers the 1st time answering a work phone or a interview call it can be hard and quite...
How to prepare for interview questions – Interview & Career tips
How to answer interview questions When you have an interview booked in, it is always good to start thinking about some possible questions you might get asked. Each sector will have sector questions relating to the specific industry that you will get asked. Below are...
Planning for a zoom or teams interview – Interview & Career tips
Planning for a zoom or teams interview Many interviews are happening via a video platform and as this has been the case for the past 2 years we’ve built a short guide to help plan for a zoom interview. If you’re searching for work you may need to attend a Zoom...
Contact us
3000 Aviator Way
Airport City Business Park
Manchester
M22 5TG
Call us:
0161 300 7862 (Northern Office)*
0203 542 6103 (Southern Office)*
Email: [email protected]